Most people assume metal lasts longer than asphalt—and technically, that’s true. But just because something lasts longer doesn’t always mean it’s better for you.
With modern asphalt shingles offering lifetime warranties and better aging than ever before, the gap isn’t as wide as it used to be—and depending on your situation, asphalt may be the smarter choice.
Traditional Thinking: Metal Outlasts Asphalt
A standard metal roof—especially standing seam—can last 40–70 years, depending on the type of metal and how it's maintained. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, have historically lasted 15–25 years.
So metal does have the edge on lifespan. But things have changed.
Modern Asphalt Shingles Are Not What They Used to Be
If you’re comparing metal to old 3-tab shingles, metal will win every time.
But if you're comparing metal to today’s architectural or designer shingles, it’s a different story.
Many asphalt shingles now come with:
- Thicker construction for impact resistance
- Improved granule adhesion to reduce wear
- Limited lifetime warranties
- Algae protection and UV resistance
In ideal conditions and with proper installation, high-performance asphalt shingles can last 30–40 years—often with better appearance retention than metal.
But There’s a Catch With Metal
Longevity doesn’t always mean maintenance-free, and it doesn’t guarantee the roof will look good for all of those years.
Over time, metal can:
- Fade or chalk from sun exposure
- Rust or streak in wet or coastal climates
- Develop visible wear that impacts curb appeal—even if the roof still functions
Caveat: Lifespan Depends on the Installer
Here’s a truth most roofers won’t say:
A great asphalt roof will outlast a poorly installed metal one.
Installation matters more than material in many cases. The contractor’s workmanship and attention to detail will either maximize or shorten your roof’s life.
Let’s Talk Cost Honestly
Metal roofing often costs 2–3 times more than asphalt—sometimes more depending on the roof’s pitch, flashings, and trim.
Caveat: That upfront cost can make sense if you plan to stay in your home for 30–50 years and value durability more than short-term aesthetics.
But if you’re planning to move in 10–15 years? You may never see that return.
Which Roof Ages More Gracefully?
This is where asphalt wins more often than people think.
- Metal fades and can look dull over time
- Scratches and dents may stand out more with age
- Asphalt shingles—especially darker tones—often hide aging more naturally
And many high-end asphalt shingle lines now mimic wood shake or slate, giving you a premium look without the premium metal price.
Sound, Style & Neighborhood Rules
Noise: Metal is louder in rain and hail unless extra insulation is added. Asphalt is naturally quieter.
HOAs & Style Guidelines: Some neighborhoods restrict metal roofing. Asphalt offers more traditional curb appeal and color flexibility.
So… Should You Choose Metal or Asphalt?
Here’s the bottom-line Marcus Sheridan-style answer:
- Choose metal if:
You’re staying long-term, value longevity over aesthetics, and don’t mind the extra upfront investment. - Choose asphalt if:
You want long-lasting performance, better short-term resale value, and a roof that’s more affordable, attractive, and easier to match to your home.
Final Caveat: There’s No One-Size-Fits-All Answer
We install both metal and asphalt roofs, and we believe both have their place. But the best roof for you depends on:
- How long you’ll stay in the home
- Your budget
- Your neighborhood and HOA rules
- How important curb appeal is to you
- And whether the installer stands behind their work
If you want to explore both options with an honest conversation and no pressure, we’d be happy to help.